Israeli city demand Google Earth to erase Nakhba - Palestinian Catastrophe - info, Google says NO!
If you want to be notified the next time I write something, sign up for FREE email alerts or subscribe to the RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
Israeli occupiers in the city of Kiryat Yam filed a police complaint to force Google to delete what they called as “false information that hurts the city’s image“.
The so called “false information” was placed a Palestinian doctor as user-generated notation placed on the image of Kiryat Yam and gives brief historical information about the location and refers to Nakhba - Palestinian Catastrophe. The notation reads:
This is one of the Palestinian localities evacuated and destroyed after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. For basic information about this locality, including brief history, the 1948 events, its current status, pictures and statistics, visit: www.palestineremembered.com.
(Click to enlarge)
The Israeli occupier complaint that “Those who see Kiryat Yam on Google Earth are told that the city was built on the ruins of an Arab town from which innocent civilians were expelled. In fact, officials said, the city was built by Holocaust survivors on land that was completely barren and had not been settled in the past. The false information was placed as part of a deliberate attempt to hurt the city’s interests, they said.”
The good news is that Google told them to “get lost” and that the altered map is “not illegal”:
While we recognize that some may find the user generated content objectionable, we are careful to balance the integrity of an open forum with the legal requirements of local governments. It looks as though this particular user-contributed annotation does not breach our Terms and Conditions nor is it in any way illegal.
The Google Earth community layer is a place where people can tag their knowledge or opinions of a location. Their comments are clearly indicated with the ‘I’ icon and this layer can easily be switched on and off.
We believe the majority of people use the community positively to share their expertise and experiences. In most cases, our users increase the utility of the product and provide a more meaningful and robust experience for each other with their contributions to the Google Earth community.
Northern Israeli town files complaint over Google claim it was built on Arab village
IHT - An Israeli town is suing Internet giant Google for slander, a local official said Monday, because a feature of its worldwide map service shows the town was built on the ruins of an Arab village.
The dispute brings together two controversies, one old and one new. Officials from the town, Kiryat Yam, deny they displaced Arabs during the war that followed Israel’s creation in 1948, and Google is defending the practice of allowing any surfer to change information in its files.
Kiryat Yam is a town of 40,000 on the Mediterranean coast just north of the port of Haifa. An entry on Google Earth, a feature that allows users to zero in on locations around the world, alleges that the town was built on the ruins of Ghawarina, an Arab village.
Hundreds of thousands of Arabs fled or were expelled during the 1948-49 war that began with Israel’s declaration of independence. Dozens of Arab villages were destroyed.
Kiryat Yam was pulled into the dispute - still one of the hottest in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict - when a Google Earth user, Thameen Darby, inserted a note on the map saying it was built on the location of Ghawarina. Darby has inserted at least 10 such notes over Google’s map of Israel.
Kiryat Yam filed a slander complaint with Israel’s police, said town official Naty Keyzilberman. “This obviously cannot be true, because Kiryat Yam was founded in 1945,” he said, explaining the police complaint.
Darby, 30, a Palestinian doctor raised in the northern West Bank town of Jenin, said his mother was a refugee from to the village Balad al-Sheikh near Kiryat Yam. His said his contributions to Google Earth are part of the “Nakhba — Palestinian Catastrophe” information hub aimed to help displaced Palestinians understand their heritage or find the villages of their parents or grandparents.
“As far as I can know, the Arab Ghawarina locality was in the place depicted,” Darby told The Associated Press. He noted that he may have not marked the exact location and if proven wrong “by reliable sources, I will be quick to reallocate it.”
Darby’s Internet Web site pinpoints Ghawarina on the site of Kiryat Yam, but another places it south of Haifa at the site of a present-day Arab town, Jisr el-Zarka. Six decades later, it is difficult to accurately locate many of the destroyed villages, leading to the conflciting claims.
Above Kiryat Yam, Darby wrote, “this is one of the Palestinian localities evacuated and destroyed after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war.”
“That’s simply complete nonsense,” Professor Yossi Ben-Artzi of Haifa University told Israeli daily Yediot Ahronot. “Kiryat Yam was built on sand dunes, and there wasn’t any Palestinian village in the area. The lands were bough in 1939 by the Gav Yam construction company.”
Asked to respond to the police complaint, a Google spokesman said Google Earth depends on user-generated content that reflects what people contribute, not what Google believes is accurate. The spokesman would not give his name, in keeping with company policy.
The spokesman insisted that the altered map is not illegal, and Google’s policy is not to remove such postings.
One point for Google!
Enjoy this post? Get future updates sent to you for free! Join by 
11 Comments on “Israeli city demand Google Earth to erase Nakhba - Palestinian Catastrophe - info, Google says NO!”
Good news about Google. I was convinced it was a Zionist organization, and actually I still am. There are many ways we can take this, but the reality is, Zionism isn’t only a Palestianian issue after all, it just seems that way because Palestinians are located in the epicenter of this global monster. But we are all targets, and we are all targeted.
Yes Karen, google is run by a dodgy lot. Google the word “Jew” and see what happens. The top site is listed as a “sponsored link” which usually means that someone has paid to ensure that their site comes out first or near the top. I think it works on an auction basis, you know, highest bidder, highest site. But this sponsored link is headed “Offensive search results” and takes you to a web page whose url is http://www.google.com/explanation. Following the link you find a big section on how some people use the word “Jew” to mean something offensive and they explain how google can’t be held responsible for that. Now that of itself is bad enough because google doesn’t do that for any other word or community. Try “Arab” or “Palestinian” for example.
But it gets worse. Follow the link and it tells you all about how google search works and it links to some discussions/articles about what Jew and Jewish means. Then it links to a google search for antisemitism, which you can imagine, throws up all mannner of zionist silencing tactics by way of distorting what the word actually antisemitism actually means.
But it gets still worse when the last link they give takes you to one of the most grotesque zionist organisations in America, the so-called Anti-Defamation League. They have played such dishonest and irresponsible games with the meaning of antisemitism some wags call them the Anti-Definition League. They have also tapped people’s phones and handed personal details of anti-racist activists to the apartheid South African government and possibly other racist regimes.
There is another objection to google and that is that they pander to repressive governments over censorship of content accessible in those countries but this is the only instance that I know of where they intervene to take sides, the zionist side, in the “free market” areas of the world wide web.
Umkahlil has a post from September 2006 that says you can download the Nakba attachment from google earth and view it. She gives the link but for some reason I couldn’t get it to work. Maybe someone else would have better luck. Here is her post with the link:
http://umkahlil.blogspot.com/2006/09/thameen-darby-creates-nakba-layer-for.html
I wonder how many other things that they want to eradicate?
Maybe me?
Maybe all others who question their motives?
This is great. Kudos to the Palestinian doctor and to Google.
Just as the Canadians caved into pressure, Google will too, we’ll have wait and see.
saa7!
let’s say.. whatever you do, this land still called
Palestine…
and to google… you have to stop playing with people just to have some damned money..!!!
Hehehe nice one Google!
Yes Google are Jews and they support the Jews as christians support christians and muslims support muslims! It’s whoever works and support his faith will get the leadership in the world. Google is listing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. Did anybody say anything? Did we complain? Woke up people.
http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=30979467&op=1&o=all&view=all&subj=2391098735&aid=-1&oid=2391098735&id=30706386
Lets start a campaign and let the world hear our voices. I would like to ask from Haitham to promote for this through his blog?
What exactly are you asking me to promote, Emad?